Springtime Surprises: 30 Delightful Easter Basket Fillers Girls Will Cherish Beyond Easter
Hello there, mom on a mission! Are you scrolling through endless Easter basket ideas, wondering how to create something special for your daughter that isn’t just another sugary collection?
We understand completely—you want her eyes to light up when she discovers her basket, but you also don’t want to contribute to that inevitable post-Easter sugar crash! This year, we’re sharing creative basket ideas that celebrate your girl’s unique personality and interests while still honoring the fun springtime tradition.
From artistic treasures to outdoor adventures and quiet-time activities, these thoughtful additions will make this Easter memorable for all the right reasons.
Can’t shop it now? Save this to Pinterest for later
Cute, Cuddly, & Wearable Spring-Themed Easter Basket Fillers For Girls
Every little girl lights up when she discovers something soft and huggable in her Easter basket! These adorable plushies and cuddly companions make perfect alternatives to candy while creating lasting memories.
Bunny Lulu Keychain
These Bunny Lulu pompom keychains are THE toy for Easter 2025! Both younger girls and tweens will love these adorable fluffy Easter companions. They come with their own cute collectible tin and are available in over a dozen colors to match your girl’s taste.
Bunny Ear Headbands
These adorable bunny ear headbands combine holiday charm with practical function for girls of all ages. Made from soft flannel that’s gentle on hair, they keep strands securely away from the face during skincare routines or makeup application.
They are a perfect Easter basket addition that serves double duty—festive Easter morning photos and everyday beauty routines!
Flower Pendant Necklace
This charming flower-shaped pendant necklace with colorful stones captures the essence of spring and makes a meaningful Easter gift for girls. Versatile enough to be placed directly in her Easter basket or used as a special egg filler, this age-appropriate jewelry piece will be treasured by girls from elementary age and through to their tweens.
A thoughtful addition to any girl’s Easter basket that celebrates growth and beauty.
Cozy Cute Bunny Slippers
These adorable fluffy bunny slippers make the perfect Easter basket addition for girls! They are both festive and practical and bring the Easter spirit while providing cozy comfort she’ll enjoy year-round. A sweet Easter gift that combines holiday charm with everyday usefulness.
- Comes in Toddler Size 5 through to Little Kids 12
- * different shades to choose from
Bunny Bracelets Cute Rabbit Charm Bracelets
These sweet silver Easter charm bracelets can be personalized with your daughter’s initial and favorite color. Presented in a beautiful gift box with a card, these nickel-free, lead-free, and cadmium-free bracelets make thoughtful Easter gifts for girls who appreciate delicate accessories.
A great non-chocolate Easter basket idea that becomes a keepsake.
Easter T-Shirt
It’s undoubtedly the season for pastels and a chance for your girl to exert her personality. From cute bunnies and Easter chicks to something a little more playful, get into the spirit of Spring and the return of t-shirt weather!
Bubbles The Purple Easter Bunny Squishmallow
Bring springtime joy to your daughter’s Easter basket with Bubbles, the irresistibly soft purple bunny Squishmallow. This cuddly companion offers the perfect combination of holiday theme and year-round comfort with its ultra-plush texture kids of all ages adore.
- Easter-themed Squishmallows also come in Buttons the Blue Easter Bunny and Valentina the Grey Easter Bunny.
Clever, Crafty, & Clued-On Easter Gifts For Girls
Spark her creativity and problem-solving skills with these engaging crafts and brain-building activities. These thoughtful Easter basket additions encourage hands-on learning while keeping her entertained for hours.
Would You Rather for Kids: Easter Edition
Bring laughter and conversation to Easter morning with this holiday-themed “Would You Rather” book. Perfect for girls who love jokes and silly scenarios, this Easter-themed question book encourages family bonding and humor.
A fantastic Easter basket idea that creates memories beyond the candy.
The Great Big Easter Activity Book
This comprehensive activity book makes an excellent non-candy Easter basket addition for girls who love mental challenges. Filled with age-appropriate coloring pages, mazes, Sudoku, and various puzzles, it provides hours of engaging entertainment while exercising critical thinking skills.
It is a thoughtful Easter gift for girls who enjoy puzzles and brain teasers.
Easter Mazes Book
Challenge your puzzle-loving daughter with this collection of 150+ entertaining mazes in three difficulty levels. This thoughtful Easter gift for girls provides hours of screen-free entertainment while building problem-solving skills.
It is an ideal non-candy Easter basket addition that keeps minds active and engaged throughout the holiday.
EggMazing Easter Egg Decorating Kit
Revolutionize your family’s Easter egg decorating tradition with this innovative EggMazing kit that kids of all ages will love. This mess-free system spins eggs while children apply markers, creating beautiful, even designs without the usual dye spills and stained fingers that parents dread.
![The EggMazing Easter Egg Mini Decorator Kit Arts and Crafts Set - Includes Egg Decorating Spinner and 6 Markers [Packaging May Vary]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41HnRYNkB5L.jpg)
- Comes with 1 spinner and 6 marker pens
- You can also add on an additional 16 marker pens for brighter and more colorful designs
Easter Basket Mad Libs
Bring laughter and wordplay to Easter morning with this holiday-themed edition of the classic Mad Libs game. With 21 “eggcellent” fill-in-the-blank stories, this interactive Easter gift for girls encourages literacy skills while providing candy-free fun.
It is the perfect game for family bonding during Easter gatherings.
LEGO Easter Bunny
This versatile LEGO Easter set inspires creativity and building skills. Perfect for LEGO enthusiasts of various ages, this 3-in-1 creator kit offers multiple building options for extended play value. You can create not just an Easter Bunny but rebuild for a llama and a seal.
- Recommended for ages 8 and up.
Easter Bunny Wind Chime Kit
This string art wind chime kit provides the perfect creative challenge for girls ready to tackle more sophisticated Easter crafts than basic egg decorating. Complete with all necessary materials to create bunny-themed wind chimes, this Easter basket addition offers a rewarding project that results in a lovely springtime decoration.
The Woobles Beginner Crochet Kit: JoJo the Bunny
Introduce your daughter to a rewarding craft with this Easter-themed beginner crochet kit featuring JoJo the Bunny. Designed specifically for first-time crocheters with child-friendly instructions, this complete Easter gift includes everything needed to create an adorable bunny keepsake.
This great, meaningful alternative to typical Easter gifts encourages skill development and screen-free entertainment.
Easter Treasure Hunt For Older Kids
Are your kids ready for a step up from the traditional egg hunt? This printable kit features challenging and thought-provoking clues to lead them to their Easter ‘treasure’. It’s perfect for kids who have outgrown simple Easter egg hunts and like a challenge.
- Sold on Etsy by RiverbridgeDesigns
Jewellrey, Accessories & Make Up Ideas For Your Older Girls
Let her feel special with these age-appropriate glamour goodies that celebrate her growing sense of style. These pretty treasures make her Easter basket feel extra magical while giving her something she can enjoy all year round. Choose items that make her feel grown-up yet remain perfectly suited for her age.
Pastel Nail Polish
Brighten her Easter morning with festive spring pastel nail polishes that girls of all ages can enjoy. Perfect for creating Easter-themed manicures or matching her holiday outfit, these polishes make delightful Easter basket additions that continue to bring joy long after the celebration.
Easter Bath Bombs
Transform bath time into a festive experience with these adorable bunny-shaped bath bombs. Girls will delight in watching these colorful, scented creations fizz and bubble.
This is a wonderful Easter basket idea that provides sensory fun without added sugar.
SpaLife Spring Facial Mask
Introduce your daughter to self-care with these spring-themed facial masks. Both playful and practical, these masks make a perfect Easter gift for girls interested in skincare and pampering activities appropriate for their age.
This set of nine masks can be gifted together or separated to create multiple Easter basket surprises.
Peeps Lip Balms
These adorable lip balms capture the fun of traditional Easter Peeps without the sugar. They are perfect for girls’ Easter baskets when you want to limit sweets or offer alternatives.
Easter Sugar Scrub
Introduce gentle skincare with these natural body scrubs in spring-inspired scents like lavender, lemon, and cherry almond. They are a thoughtful Easter gift for girls beginning to develop their personal care routine.
- Sold by Sassygirlboutique
Available in appealing pastel colors perfect for Easter, these scrubs make a refreshing alternative to traditional Easter basket fillers.
Some Bunny Loves You Easter Candle
This adorable vegan-friendly soy candle from Etsy seller WaxonFire comes in various sizes and scents to match your daughter’s preferences. It is a sophisticated yet sweet Easter basket idea that appeals to girls who are developing their own style and home décor interests.
- Sold by WaxonFire on Etsy
More Easter-Themed Toy Ideas & Basket Stuffers
Celebrate the season with these springtime toys and Easter-themed goodies that capture the magic of the holiday. These playful additions bring festive fun to her basket while offering more lasting enjoyment than chocolate eggs.
Mood Change Eggs
Looking for something different than traditional chocolate for your girl’s Easter basket? These fascinating color-changing eggs offer a fun alternative that girls of all ages will be amazed by. Responding to body heat, these eggs transform through five different colors when held.
- Beautifully gift-boxed by Mommysmuddleddeddesigns, they make a unique and engaging Easter gift for girls.
Easter Basket Stuffers
Simplify your Easter preparations with this bulk pack of Easter-themed fidget toys. These sensory toys appeal to children of all ages, making them perfect Easter basket fillers for multiple children.
Easter Galaxy Slime Eggs
Surprise and delight with these unique Easter eggs filled with stretchy, metallic galaxy slime. This tactile toy combines the traditional egg hunt experience with the sensory play children enjoy from elementary to teen years.
This is a great modern Easter basket addition that provides hours of hands-on entertainment without the dentist bills!
Bunny Booty Cotton Candy
If you’re still looking for something sweet to include in your girl’s Easter basket, surprise her with this whimsical treat! This fluffy blue cotton candy hidden in a bunny’s “secret stash” adds a playful touch without the heaviness of chocolate eggs.
A simple but fun addition to your Easter basket ideas for girls.
Easter Bunny Money
When you’re unsure about specific preferences or want to give her some independence, this creative “Bunny Money” offers the perfect solution. It’s a charming way to present cash or gift cards in her Easter basket, allowing her to select her own special treat or contribute to her savings.
- You’ll find these cute Bunny Money gift tags from CozyCabinRI on Etsy.
Digital Easter Coupon
Need a last-minute Easter basket addition? These printable gift coupons provide instant solutions. Download, edit to your needs, and print immediately to create personalized promises for special activities, privileges, or experiences.
- Sold by ThePrintedSmile on Etsy.
- Requires basic editing skills using free Canva online
Easter Gift Card
Complete her Easter basket with an Amazon gift card in special Easter-themed packaging. A simple Easter basket idea that gives her both a surprise on Easter morning and the anticipation of choosing her own special item later.
Ready-Made Easter Baskets
If you’re feeling short on inspiration or don’t have the time to run around for bits and bobs for your girls’s basket, fear not, as there are many clearly crafted pre-made gift baskets you can buy for girls through platforms such as Etsy.
Filled Easter Basket for Girls
Give your daughter a special treat with this thoughtfully prefilled Easter basket. Packed with age-appropriate beauty items, sweet treats, and fun goodies, this ready-to-go Easter gift will delight girls of all ages.
It is perfect for busy parents looking for a complete Easter basket solution that girls will enjoy long after the holiday has passed.
- Created by BasketsandBoxesShop
Queen of Crafts Easter Basket
Create a memorable Easter morning with this delightful pamper box, which girls from elementary to teen years will adore. Filled with beauty essentials, cozy socks, and special beauty treats, there’s plenty in here for your girl and special treats. This Easter gift offers immediate joy and items she’ll use for months.
- Sold by SweetMarbella on Etsy
We hope you found something in this selection that will inspire your girl’s Easter basket this year.
Got other family members to shop for? You may also want to check out next:
- Cute ideas for including in your Toddler’s Easter Basket
- All the Best Easter Gift Ideas for Boys
- Tweens and teens think they’ve outgrown Easter Baskets? Some more mature Easter gift ideas for teens to try
More Easter Celebration Ideas
- Hosting Easter Brunch this year? Turn your appetizers into conversation starters with these Easter appetizers that are too cute to eat
- For a dessert that looks as good as it tastes, try making some cute and colorful Easter treats, inspired by spring pastels and festive themes – plus our collection of awesome Easter Peeps recipes!
- Whether you prefer sweet or savory, these Easter charcuterie boards offer the perfect mix of flavors for a festive grazing table.
- Celebrate with style by serving these beautiful non-alcoholic Easter mocktails, which bring a refreshing taste of spring to any gathering.
© Little Party Pixie 2025
