How to Create the Perfect Teen Boo Basket for Your Bestie

There’s something magical about surprising your friends with a thoughtful gift, and boo baskets have become the ultimate way to show you care during spooky season. If you’ve been scrolling through Pinterest and wondering how to put together your first boo basket, you’re in the right place.

Creating a boo basket for your friend doesn’t have to be complicated or expensive—it’s all about choosing items that’ll make them smile and feel appreciated.

Can’t shop now? Save these ideas to Pinterest for later

We also have guides to the best Boo Basket Fillers for Kids and how to prepare a family Boo Basket for neighbors and friends

How to Make a Boo Basket for Your BFF

While there are some amazing, cute premade packs you can grab if you’re pressed for time (we’ll get to them below!), we absolutely love the personal touch that comes with putting together your own basket.

There’s something special about choosing each item with your friend in mind, and honestly, it’s pretty fun to put together too. First, we’ll walk through it step by step how to construct a fun and personalized basket, then we’ll dive into our list of must-have items.

2. Create That Aesthetic Base

Layer in some tissue paper or crinkled paper to make everything look fuller and more put-together. Stick with classic Halloween vibes—black, orange, and deep purple—or switch it up with fall colors like burgundy and gold if that’s more their style. This step is what makes your basket look professional instead of like you just threw everything in a bag.

3. Sweet Treats That Hit Different

Obviously, you need candy, but think beyond basic trick-or-treat stuff. Grab their favorite chocolate bars, some fun seasonal flavors like pumpkin pie Kit Kats, or those viral TikTok candies everyone’s talking about. If they’re into healthier options, consider adding dark chocolate, fancy granola bars, or those Instagram-worthy fruit gummies that actually taste good.

4. Fun Extras That Aren’t Just Candy

This is where you can get creative and show you really know them. Consider adding face masks (the skincare kind or fun Halloween ones), cute stickers for their laptop or water bottle, or even some seasonal lip balm flavors. Bath bombs, mini candles, or small plants are also perfect if they’re into self-care or room decor.

Cutsey Halloween GIFT IDEAS

SEASONAL PERSONAL CARE

5. Wearable Fall Vibes

Include something they can actually use during the season. Think scrunchies in fall colors, a cute beanie, Halloween-themed jewelry, or even a small scarf. If they’re really into fashion, a pair of orange or black earrings could be perfect. The key is choosing something that matches their personal style, not just anything Halloween-related.

6. Cozy Season Essentials

Fall is all about getting comfy, so lean into those cozy vibes. Fuzzy socks or slippers are always a win, especially ones with cute Halloween or fall patterns. A small throw blanket for movie nights, a seasonal mug they can use for hot chocolate or coffee, or even some fancy hot cocoa packets or fall-flavored tea bags. These items say “let’s get cozy together” and give major hygge energy that everyone loves during the colder months.

7. Something for the Long Game

Add an item that’ll stick around after Halloween passes. A cute notebook they can use at school, a small book (especially if they’re into thrillers or YA), or even a Halloween-themed puzzle they can do with their family. If they’re into journaling or planning, some cute pens or washi tape work great too.

8. Make It Look Professional

Finish everything with a handwritten note explaining the boo basket tradition (and why you picked them), then wrap it up with cellophane and a ribbon, or just arrange everything so it looks intentional. Take a cute pic before you deliver it—you’ll definitely want it for your stories.

---

Add a Sweet Message

A Boo Basket feels even more special when you include a little note. It’s a chance to add your own personality, whether you want to be funny, thoughtful, or a little spooky. A message can also explain the tradition—letting your BFF know they’ve been “booed” and encouraging them to pass the fun along.

For teens, it’s less about rules and more about making the gift feel personal, like a mix of a friendship card and a Halloween surprise.

Here are some message ideas you could write on a card, tuck into the basket, or print out as a cute tag:

Playful & Punny

• You’ve been officially BOO’d! No tricks, just treats from me to you.
• Witch-ing you the happiest spooky season—now it’s your turn to BOO someone too!
• You’ve got great taste… and now some great treats too!
• Fangs for being my bestie—enjoy this BOO Basket!

Sweet & Friendship-Focused

• Just a little basket to remind you how much you mean to me.
• Besties make Halloween even sweeter—boo to you, BFF!
• Here’s a spooky surprise to brighten your day—thanks for always being the best friend.
• No ghosting here—just me BOOing my favorite person.

Encouraging Pay-It-Forward

• You’ve been BOOed! Keep the fun going and surprise someone else with a basket.
• This BOO Basket is yours to enjoy—now spread the spook and make someone else smile.
• Pass it on: give a little treat to another friend and keep the tradition alive!

Mini Boo: Small but Mighty

Not everyone needs a full basket situation. Sometimes a tiny gesture hits just as hard—enter the mini boo! Grab a small gift box, mason jar, cute seasonal mug, or even a takeout container and fill it with just a few sweet things: their favorite candy, a face mask, and a kind note.

These work perfectly when you’re on a budget, want to surprise multiple friends, or prefer keeping things simple. Mini boo boxes are also great for leaving in lockers, on car windshields, or anywhere a big basket would be awkward to deliver.

Short on Time? No Problem

If you’re feeling overwhelmed or just want something ready to go, you can totally find pre-made boo baskets on Amazon or Etsy that look amazing and save you the shopping time. Sometimes it’s worth spending a little extra for something that’s already put together perfectly, especially if you’re doing this at the last minute.

Amazon Pre-Filled Boo-Boxes

Etsy Pre-FILLED Boo Baskets

Are You Ready to Enter the Boo Basket Tradition?

Creating a boo basket is really about showing someone you were thinking of them, not about spending tons of money or making it Pinterest-perfect. Focus on including a few things you know they’ll love, add some seasonal touches, and don’t stress too much about making it “right.”

Your friend will appreciate the thought you put into it way more than whether you picked the perfect ribbon color. Now go spread some fall happiness!

© Little Party Pixie 2025