Cute Easter Basket Ideas for Toddlers That Make Magic Memories
Those early toddler years are fleeting! Create wonderful memories and start new Easter traditions with these toddler Easter basket ideas
Watching a toddler discover the magic of Easter morning might just be one of parenthood’s sweetest joys! But if you’re like many moms, you’re probably wondering how to create that special moment without loading up on sugary treats that your little one doesn’t need (and might not even enjoy yet!).
Finding the perfect balance of delightful and developmentally appropriate Easter basket fillers can feel challenging, but we’ve got you covered.
From sensory toys that fascinate tiny hands to spring-themed books and cuddly companions, these toddler-friendly Easter basket ideas will create wonderful memories while respecting your little one’s needs and your parenting choices.
Can’t shop it now? Save these ideas to Pinterest for later
NB – Toddlers to Preschoolers covers a broad developmental age group so use your best judgement when gifting any toys with small parts.
Personalized Easter Gift Basket
Start your little one’s Easter tradition with a personalized basket they’ll use for years to come! We love these adorable woven cotton rope baskets; they make the perfect foundation for your toddler’s Easter morning surprise. They are a must-have for creating memorable Easter baskets for toddlers that will hold treasured goodies and become cherished keepsakes for future egg hunts.
- Several color combinations are available for boys and girls for the basket rope and lettering
- Personalized names of messages (up to 8 characters recommended)
- Made by LiWorks on Etsy
The Classic Tale of Peter Rabbit
Introduce your toddler to Easter’s most beloved bunny with this timeless hardcover treasure. Beatrix Potter’s classic story makes one of the most enchanting Easter gifts for toddlers, combining beautiful illustrations with gentle storytelling.
This charming addition to your toddler’s Easter basket creates magical moments while building their first library collection.
- Suitable from 6 months to 6 years.
Peter Rabbit Plushy
Complete your toddler’s Easter basket with this irresistibly soft Peter Rabbit plushy! Perfect for tiny hands to hold and love, this adorable companion brings the beloved storybook character to life.
One of our most popular Easter basket fillers for toddlers, this cuddly friend is sure to become your little one’s new naptime favorite.
- 9.5 inches tall
- Easter chicks are sewn in
Hippity, Hoppity, Little Bunny
This sturdy board book with built-in finger puppet brings Easter magic to story time! Designed specifically for little hands, it’s an ideal Easter basket idea for toddlers just discovering books.
The interactive puppet engages curious minds while introducing Easter traditions through delightful rhymes that parents will enjoy reading again and again.
- 12 thick cardboard pages
- Suitable 0-3 years
Easter Sensory Kit
Spark imagination and sensory development with this spring-themed exploration kit! Perfect for toddlers over 3, this unique Easter basket filler includes stretchy play dough, textured bunnies, chicks, and carrots. Give the gift of hands-on discovery while creating magical Easter memories that engage all their developing senses.
- Hours of entertainment packed into one pre-made kit.
- A minimum age of 3 years is required due to the small parts
- By Etsy seller HappyKitsCorner
Easter Mini Bubbles
Watch your little one’s face light up with these festive bubble wands! These chick and bunny-themed tubes make perfect Easter basket fillers for toddlers who love outdoor play. Easy for small hands to manage, these bubbles bring springtime joy while developing coordination skills—a delightful addition to any toddler Easter basket.
- 4.2″ long with 20 pieces in a set
- Recommend for ages 3+
Easter Suction Cup Spinner Toys
These colorful Easter-themed spinners stick to smooth surfaces for mess-free entertainment! Featuring adorable chicks, bunnies, and eggs, they’re perfectly sized for toddler hands. A creative Easter basket idea for toddlers that combines festive fun with developing fine motor skills and visual tracking during playtime.
- Comes in a 3-pack with 12 detachable pieces
- Recommended from 1 year+
Wooden Easter Egg Shakers
Introduce your little one to rhythm and music with these beautifully crafted wooden egg shakers! Each colorful, hand-painted egg in a springtime theme creates gentle sounds that fascinate developing ears.
These non-toxic musical instruments make perfect Easter basket fillers for toddlers, encouraging sensory play while fitting perfectly with your spring theme.
I Spy Easter Bunny
Turn Easter morning into an adventure with this engaging hidden picture book! This colorful search-and-find includes bonus coloring pages for creative expression, a perfect Easter gift for toddlers developing observation skills.
Snuggle up together and hunt for hidden bunnies—creating memories beyond the Easter basket..
- Suitable for 2 to 5-year-olds
- 37 pages
Toddler Easter Treasure Hunt
Transform Easter morning into an exciting adventure with this specially designed hunt for little explorers! This is one of our favorite unique Easter basket ideas for preschoolers learning to follow simple instructions. With parent-friendly clues and adorable Easter-themed “treasures,” this game creates magical memories while building problem-solving skills.
- You could include the starting clue in their basket or have the basket be the treasure!
- Ready for instant download at DesignAholics on Etsy
Burt’s Bees Girls’ Pajamas
Start Easter morning in style with these 100% organic cotton PJs! Machine-washable and incredibly soft, these adorable jammies make Easter photos extra special. They’re a practical yet festive addition to your toddler’s Easter basket that combines comfort with holiday cheer—perfect for Easter morning excitement and year-round snuggles.
- Sized 12 months through to 12 years.
Wooden Name Tag
Add a special personal touch to your toddler’s Easter basket with this beautiful wooden name tag! This charming keepsake can adorn their basket year after year, creating a sweet tradition.
A thoughtful Easter gift for toddlers that adds meaning while making basket identification easy during community egg hunts.
- Bunny or Chick designs
Toddler Bunny House Slippers
Keep tiny toes toasty with these impossibly cute bunny slippers! A practical yet adorable Easter basket filler for toddlers that brings holiday charm to everyday routines. Their delighted expression when discovering these fuzzy friends in their Easter basket will be worth every penny—Easter morning magic guaranteed!
- Available in 10 colors with sizing from 4 infant to 5 Big Kids
Toomies Hide & Squeak Eggs
This classic toy deserves a spot in every toddler Easter basket! Match colored eggs and chicks while developing fine motor skills and color recognition.
A timeless Easter gift for toddlers that promotes learning through play and will last long after the chocolate has disappeared—creating springtime fun for years to come.
ArtCreativity Stacking Egg Toys
These pastel stacking eggs are the Easter basket filler that keeps on giving! Perfect for bath time, travel, or everyday play, they’ll entertain your toddler long after Easter morning. These versatile toys make wonderful Easter gifts for toddlers by combining festive spring colors with developmental benefits like spatial awareness and hand-eye coordination.
- 7 piece nesting set
- Ideal from age 3 and up
Easter Baskets with Ear Headbands
Equip your little bunny with this adorable carrying basket and matching ear headband for their first egg hunt! Perfectly sized for tiny hands, it’s more manageable than their main Easter basket. Create Instagram-worthy moments while collecting goodies—an essential Easter basket idea for toddlers joining the hunting tradition!
- This set has 6 baskets and matching ears, so it’s great for a group!
Older Kids? We have plenty more ideas for your growing kids, divided into Easter Baskets for Boys and Inspiring Girl Easter Basket ideas. Once your kids hit 12+, visit our teen Easter ideas page for further inspiration.
More Easter Ideas
Are you hosting an Easter Brunch this year or simply looking for fun ways to celebrate the season with your little ones? We have plenty more ideas to help with your Easter planning. Why not read next:
- Easy Easter Crafts, perfect for younger children.
- So much more to Easter than just egg hunts! Fun outdoor games to play this Easter.
- Turn your appetizers into conversation starters with these Easter appetizers that are too cute to eat
- Swert tooth? Try making some cute and colorful Easter treats inspired by spring pastels and a festive theme; some of the kids can even lend a helping hand.
- Whether you prefer sweet or savory, these Easter charcuterie boards offer the perfect mix of flavors for a festive grazing table.
- Celebrate with style by serving these beautiful non-alcoholic Easter mocktails bring a refreshing taste of spring to any gathering.
© Little Party Pixie 2025
